What continues to amaze me is the level of discourse Star Wars in general and Episode I - The Phantom Menace in particular gets, among fans. Honestly, we never stopped talking about it. The conversation now centers on the merits of the film, out of the glare of the blinding hype that accompanied its release. Most people tend to agree now it was not as bad as we first thought. It's not even the worst Star Wars film.
A lot of the conversation that takes place around TPM and the prequels centers on the 'what if;' what if Jar Jar hadn't existed, what if this or that. If I had a nickel for every conversation I have had with Ben, Sugu or any of my friends on this subject, I'd be able to finance my own version of the movie. And I admit - I have, off and on, been writing a screenplay of a revised Episode I for a long time. It serves primarly as a mental exercise. Whenever I need to limber up, or get the pistons firing, I tinker at this script. What's most fascinating to me about this subject besides its persistence is the fervor. You don't hear anyone carrying torches for how 'The Godfather 3' should have been. The need for TPM and the prequels to somehow be reimagined speaks both to the quality of the films in the first place, and a unique creative trend that actually has been alive and well for a long time - fan fiction.
This video below stakes out pretty common ground - with a few major exceptions - of where TPM revisionists line up, myself included. Some of the language is NSFW, FYI.
This is pretty funny, and if I knew all you had to do was sit in front of a green screen and pontificate on what should have been, I'd simply have done that. The guy in the video offers a version of TPM which is at once both better, and less, than the original.
Where I agree:
- This is really Obi-Wan Kenobi's story. Obi-Wan himself sets this up in his conversation with Luke in 'Star Wars,' about the Clone Wars, and convincing Anakin to join him on an 'idealistic crusade.' As it stands, we never see this because Obi-Wan is neutered as a character by Qui-Gon Jinn. Liam Neeson is simply the best thing about TPM, but his character serves only to echo a thematic element of the original movie. Obi-Wan is relegated to a bystander and as such his relationship and stake in the story is undercut from the beginning.
- Darth Maul lives. It seems the cartoon is waking up to correcting this major mistake. Darth Maul should have survived the film, and remained the prequels' Big Bad.
- Anakin is older. Him being a kid - doesn't work. Will never work.
Most everyone wants the Clone Wars to begin with Episode I, and I did for a very long time, but actually it's necessary they don't; we must see the Jedi to be incapable of defeating this new enemy on their own. As such, the Gungans - maybe even Jar Jar - become necessary to pulling out a victory, hollow as it is. The clones come second, in response to the percieved inability of the Jedi. The Separatist cause, and Count Dooku, they should come right away, though, and the way the clones arrive in Episode II simply doesn't work.
Ok, ok - DORK OVERLOAD. The real point of this is - fans are writing, in their heads, on computers, or on video. We're writing a version of a story that already exists. This is a new kind of writing, and it's not; people have been re-writing stories to fit their needs and circumstances from the beginning (Gilgamesh) but what you have in Star Wars, or Harry Potter fan fiction, is a particular investment that unfortunately runs up against a couple barriers - art and commerce.
It's very rare those two things work together, but traditionally they have against fan fiction. Fan fiction typically isn't though of as art, and its commercial prospects are nil due to copyright concerns. So, until recently, it has languished in notebooks and the occasional fan magazine. With the internet, fan fiction is taking on a life of its own, to the point some writers are creating universes for their fans to play in. The subject is bigger than this blog post, but so many ideas intersect here - ownership, art, commerce, joy - that it's endlessly debatable.
I love Star Wars. I love TPM. I suppose I'll always argue the film, and write its wrongs (wow) in my head or in my punching bag of a script.